Sacboyz NFL Picks

Education-first NFL decision framework prototype. No live data, no guarantees, no lock language.

Fixture Release: READY Docs Publish: REVIEW NEEDED Live Calls: DISABLED Human Review: REQUIRED

Decision Summary

Fixture Release Readiness: PASS (Ready for release)
Docs Publish Readiness: REVIEW NEEDED (Docs validation pending)
Live API Calls Status: DISABLED (Offline/Fixture mode enforced)
Human Review Gate: REQUIRED (Offline gate review mandatory)
Top Blockers & Actions:
  • Ryan/Sacboyzone or more live providers are not selected
  • Ryan/Sacboyzapprove live providers
  • Codex Ownedadd sanitized provider schema fixtures
  • Codex Ownedconfigure live provider environment variables

Reviewer Handoff Checklist

Reviewer Stacked PR Handoff Instructions

To inspect and validate the stacked report PRs before merge:

  1. Run the local quality gate to verify all tests and validations pass: python run_quality_gate.py
  2. Verify git status contains no unexpected modifications: git status --short

*Note: All live-provider adapter calls remain disabled by design. These PRs represent stacked work and will remain stacked until Chris and Claude return for a final review.*

Reviewer "What Changed" Summary

Changed Artifacts: Rebuilt static report HTMLs, sitemaps, checklists, and JSON definitions to reflect polished reviewer copy and print query formatting.

Validation State: PASS (All 77 handoff artifacts validated successfully against offline schemas; sitemaps fully populated).

No-Live-Call Safety: ENFORCED (Confirmed zero live REST or WebSocket queries to providers; runtime defaults to live_no_call).

PR Review Order Print Snapshot

Follow this sequential order to inspect and approve the stacked PRs:

  1. PR #24 (codex/provider-samples-backlog): Review baseline provider decisions and JSON structures.
  2. PR #25 (codex/live-v1-provider-foundation): Verify initial provider live connection hooks.
  3. PR #26 (antigravity/report-docs-polish): Inspect report landing layouts and CSS variables.
  4. PR #27 (antigravity/report-qa-polish): Verify conservative empty states and quality gate scripts.
  5. PR #28 (antigravity/report-accessibility-polish): Review table caption elements and aria labels.
  6. PR #29 (antigravity/report-mobile-print-polish): Inspect print query stylesheets and narrow screen layouts.
  7. PR #30 (antigravity/report-reviewer-flow-polish): Review relative link paths and sitemap integrity.
  8. PR #31 (antigravity/reviewer-artifact-map-polish): Verify artifact maps and decision guidelines.
  9. PR #32 (antigravity/report-reviewer-queue-polish): Inspect action item backlogs and priority tags.
  10. PR #33 (antigravity/report-release-review-polish): Review handoff summaries and release bundle paths.
  11. PR #34 (antigravity/report-decision-summary-polish): Verify final decision badges and mock slates.
  12. PR #35 (antigravity/report-review-checklist-polish): Inspect handoff checklist checkbox elements.
  13. PR #36 (antigravity/report-final-review-polish): Review skip-link accessibility anchors.
  14. PR #37 (antigravity/report-final-qa-polish): Verify conservative empty-state fallback messages.
  15. PR #38 (antigravity/report-review-index-polish): Review glossary boxes and mockup index page headers.
  16. PR #39 (antigravity/report-reviewer-print-final): Verify print-safe panel colors and link audit checks.
  17. PR #40 (antigravity/report-reviewer-final-polish): Verify consolidated final QA checklists, glossaries, and print layouts.
  18. PR #41 (antigravity/report-reviewer-final-qa): Verify landing page QA metrics, sitemaps, link warnings, and copy consistency.
  19. PR #42 (antigravity/report-reviewer-review-guide): Current PR. Verify landing page stack review guides and evidence table styling.

Reviewer Final QA

Review Order: PR #24 → PR #42 (Chronological stacked branch path verification).

Current Stacked PR Lane: Antigravity report-reviewer-review-guide (Final reviewer stack flow documentation guide and evidence table styling).

Quality Gate Expectation: Local gate checks (pytest test suites, secret scans, provider decisions, artifact schemas) must pass 100% cleanly.

No Live Provider Calls: ENFORCED (All live provider integration calls are disabled by default).

Generated Artifact Changed: YES (Recompiled static HTML reports, sitemaps, checklists, and packet markdown files).

How to Review This Stack

Follow these steps to systematically verify the entire branch sequence:

  1. Step 1: Check baseline provider fixtures (Inspect PR #24 provider-samples-backlog and verify offline intake data models).
  2. Step 2: Verify adapter connections (Inspect PR #25 live-v1-provider-foundation and confirm zero live connection leaks).
  3. Step 3: Review UI report presentation (Verify navigation bars, progression lines, print-friendly CSS styles, and accessibility headings from PR #26 to PR #37).
  4. Step 4: Audit index links & glossary cards (Verify relative sitemap links, local hashes, and key terminology glossaries from PR #38 to PR #42).
  5. Step 5: Run quality gate validation (Execute python run_quality_gate.py to confirm sitemaps, secret scanning, and pytest suites pass cleanly).

Reviewer Glossary & Key Terms

No Play: Candidate does not meet the necessary threshold requirements or is filtered out due to active risk gates. Systematic abstention is enforced to manage variance.

Review: Candidate is in a cautionary state requiring human verification (e.g., pending key player status or final inactives confirmations).

Risk Flag: An alert indicating potential elevated risk, such as extreme weather, rapid line movement, or defensive matchup anomalies.

Best Line: The optimal wagering line selected dynamically after shopping multiple books for the best available price.

Market Confirmation: Verification that a candidate is supported by consensus across multiple independent bookmakers.

Offline Fixture: Standard operating state using pre-packaged, offline fixture data for testing, simulation, and schema validation.

Live Disabled: Safe default status indicating that live REST or WebSocket network connections to third-party data providers are completely shut off.

Candidates-
Actionable/Lean-
Review-
No Play-
Source Issues-
Scenarios-

By State

    By Market

      By Window

        Top Gates

          Scenario Coverage

            Top Candidates

              Understanding Selections

              Seeding and categorization are based on quantitative modeling edge, strictly avoiding guarantees or lock language:

              • A / B / Lean Candidates: Candidate or lean signals with supporting model edge and context; team-market leans remain review-first in V1.
              • Review: Selections requiring human review, often due to injury updates or tight edge margins.
              • Fade / No Play (Abstain): Discarded candidates where edge is negative (fade) or where safety checks prohibit plays.

              System Constraints & Safety

              Robust operational guardrails applied automatically to filter selections:

              • Hidden Gates: Systematic background checks (e.g. line-movements, player status) that filter candidates out if thresholds are breached.
              • Source Health: Feed validation checks assessing whether provider streams are fresh, complete, and within contract terms.
              • Provider Readiness & Live Blockers: Integration checklists ensuring all normalizers pass validation before live data is wiring-ready.

              Reviewer Artifact Trail

              Live Review

              Verify live readiness blockers, checklist status, and blocker queues:

              Provider Samples

              Inspect provider schema validation, cross-family consistency, and summaries:

              Release & Publishing

              Review release-readiness bundles and static publish indicators:

              Fixture QA

              Check scenario coverage metrics and threshold calibration cards:

              Handoff Docs

              Read developer setup, workspace configurations, and checklist files:

              Core Report

              Mock NFL ReportStatic report generated from the fixture slate. Report SummaryCompact JSON counts for external status surfaces. Candidate RankingsCompact sorted feed of candidates, scores, best lines, and risks. Next Action QueueMachine-readable safe offline, decision-needed, and blocked work lanes. Next Action Queue ReportReadable queue separating fixture-mode work from live-provider dependencies.

              Fixture QA

              Fixture Scenario CoverageMachine-readable no-live-data coverage for states, gates, and review paths. Fixture Scenario Coverage ReportReadable QA matrix for mock slate gate coverage. Settled Tracker SampleFixture settlement output with win, loss, push, no-action, and correlation weights. Backtest Summary SampleMarket-level summary generated from the settled tracker fixture. Calibration ReviewThreshold-review rollups by market, edge bucket, book agreement, matchup, injury, and script. Calibration ReportReadable threshold-review cards with small-sample warnings. Market Health SampleMarket, confidence, and state rollups generated from settled tracker output. Market Health ReportReadable lifecycle recommendation cards by market. Baseline ComparisonMachine-readable fixture-vs-sample baseline comparison. Baseline Comparison ReportReadable comparison of fixture and sanitized sample-baseline outputs. Source Health ReviewMachine-readable review of fixture and sanitized sample source-health gates. Source Health Review ReportReadable PASS/REVIEW/ABSTAIN source-health lane review.

              Provider Readiness

              Adapter RegistryFixture and future live-provider adapter boundaries. Adapter ReadinessMachine-readable live-adapter and normalizer coverage by feed family. Adapter Readiness ReportReadable adapter coverage and live-readiness gaps. Provider Fixture StatusMachine-readable readiness for sanitized provider schema samples. Provider Fixture ReportReadable status for provider sample folders and missing schema fixtures. Provider Selection RubricMachine-readable approval proof needed before future live providers. Provider Selection Rubric ReportReadable provider approval criteria without enabling live mode. Provider Decision SummaryMachine-readable locked V1 provider defaults and no-call status. Provider Decision Summary ReportReadable provider defaults and live-gate safety summary. Environment ReadinessSecret-safe live environment variable readiness summary. Environment Readiness ReportReadable secret-safe environment readiness summary. Quota ReadinessNo-call Odds API quota-state readiness summary. Quota Readiness ReportReadable no-call quota-state review. Provider Schema TemplatesTemplate-only payload shapes derived from data-source contracts. Provider Schema Template ReportReadable template family review for future sanitized provider samples. Provider Sample RequestSanitized schema sample request packet for future provider review. Provider Sample Request ReportReadable schema sample request packet and redaction rules. Provider Sample IntakeMachine-readable intake checklist for approved sanitized provider samples. Provider Sample Intake ReportReadable intake actions before provider sample collection. Provider Sample ValidationMachine-readable validation of sanitized provider sample files. Provider Sample Validation ReportReadable provider sample validation status by source family. Provider Sample ConsistencyMachine-readable cross-family checks for sanitized provider samples. Provider Sample Consistency ReportReadable cross-family sample consistency diagnostics. Provider Sample Redaction AuditMachine-readable redaction audit for sanitized provider sample files. Provider Sample Redaction Audit ReportReadable redaction findings before sample adapter review. Provider Sample Review SummaryCompact provider sample request, intake, validation, and redaction status. Provider Sample Review Summary ReportReadable provider sample handoff summary and next action. Provider Sample Collection PacketCopy-ready checklist for future sanitized provider sample collection. Provider Dry RunNo-call provider dry-run plan by source family. Provider Dry Run ReportReadable no-call provider dry-run plan. Live Provider ReviewMachine-readable no-call provider-review clearance summary. Live Provider Review ReportReadable provider-review evidence and remaining holds. Live Switch PrecheckMachine-readable precheck before any future runtime switch change. Live Switch Precheck ReportReadable switch target and approval precheck summary. Network Guard AuditMachine-readable source scan for direct network calls. Network Guard Audit ReportReadable no-call network guard audit. Runtime Mode MatrixMachine-readable fixture/sample/live-no-call/live policy matrix. Runtime Mode Matrix ReportReadable runtime mode and quota policy matrix.

              Release/Publish Readiness

              Release ReadinessCombined bundle, provider, secret, and artifact validation status. Release Readiness ReportReadable handoff readiness status. Release BundleStandalone repo handoff checklist in machine-readable form. Release NotesLatest completed work and generated artifact list. Review PacketConcise Markdown rollup for human release review. Handoff SummaryCompact release status, artifact, quality-gate, and readiness summary. Artifact IndexGenerated file listing with sizes and artifact types. Artifact SummaryCompact artifact type counts, total bytes, and largest generated outputs. Build SummaryHuman-readable summary of the latest fixture build. Build Status JSONMachine-readable status parsed from the build status handoff document. Docs Publish ReadinessMachine-readable Cloudflare Pages static payload readiness. Docs Publish Readiness ReportReadable static docs publishing readiness without contacting Cloudflare. Site MapStatic docs and mock artifact listing for publishing review. Run ManifestMachine-readable record of generated artifacts and validation status. Check SchemaSix visible checks for report and UI consumers. Threshold SchemaConfig-driven baby lines and edge thresholds by market. Market ScopeV1 player props, team markets, and deferred markets. Data Source ContractsRequired and optional fields for future live feed adapters.

              Repo/Handoff Docs

              ArchitectureModule map and runtime entrypoints. Data DictionaryGenerated tracker, audit, rankings, and calibration fields. Framework PlanBuild-ready technical and product plan. Build BacklogIssue-style roadmap for implementation. Build StatusCurrent implementation and verification status. Live Provider ConfigFuture live-mode environment variables and fail-closed expectations. Local DevelopmentFixture-mode commands, quality gate, and release-safety notes. Provider DecisionsApproval register for future live data sources. Release ChecklistPre-publish checks for the standalone GitHub repo. Remote SetupGitHub and Cloudflare Pages setup checklist. Backlog SummaryMachine-readable issue, milestone, and pending-production summary. GitHub Issues SeedIssue-ready JSON generated from the implementation backlog. GitHub Labels SeedLabel taxonomy generated from the implementation backlog. GitHub Milestones SeedMilestone taxonomy generated from the implementation backlog. GitHub Backlog BundleCombined labels, milestones, and issues for remote repo setup. GitHub Backlog ReportReadable review page for labels, milestones, and issues before remote import. Quality Gate PlanMachine-readable command plan for local and CI handoff validation. Season ReadinessMachine-readable season phase and live-pick availability guard. Season Readiness ReportReadable offseason/live-pick availability status. Repo Setup StatusMachine-readable standalone Git and remote-publish readiness check. Repo Setup Status ReportReadable standalone Git and remote-publish readiness check. Repo InventoryRepository file counts by area and suffix. Live ReadinessMachine-readable blocker summary for future live-mode enablement. Live Readiness ReportReadable live-mode blocker summary separate from fixture readiness. Live Enablement ChecklistMachine-readable gate separating online prep from live calls. Live Enablement Checklist ReportReadable gate review before live provider calls. Live Preflight SummaryCompact no-call Live V1 go/no-go summary. Live Preflight Summary ReportReadable Live V1 preflight gate summary. Live Blocker QueueRanked no-call action queue for Live V1 blockers. Live Blocker Queue ReportReadable blocker ownership and next-action queue. Live Go/No-GoMachine-readable no-call Live V1 approval review packet. Live Go/No-Go PacketCopy-ready Live V1 go/no-go checklist for human review. Live Activation ChecklistMachine-readable future live activation checklist. Live Activation Checklist ReportReadable activation checklist and remaining holds. Live Activation PlanMachine-readable staged activation plan. Live Activation Plan ReportReadable staged activation plan and current phase. Live Calls RehearsalMachine-readable no-call rehearsal summary. Live Calls Rehearsal ReportReadable calls-only staging rehearsal checklist. Live Approval RecordMachine-readable approval template for future calls-only staging. Live Approval Record ReportReadable no-call approval record and pending signoffs. Live Activation AuditMachine-readable no-call activation audit trail. Live Activation Audit ReportReadable activation audit events and remaining holds.